Tony's Pizza Menu (Update 2026)

Tony's Pizza offers a wide selection of specialty pies that truly cater to every craving. The Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza, featuring stuffed goodness, has become a local favorite. With the menu boasting 37 unique pizzas, including options like BBQ Chicken and the famous Sicilian slice, Tony's promises something exciting for any palate. If you're feeling adventurous, try the Baked Ziti Pizza or indulge in classic garlic knots and zeppoles. Each option expertly blends flavors, ensuring meals are satisfying and memorable. Desserts like cheesecake and cannoli sweeten the experience, making it a perfect spot for any foodie.

Tony's Specialty Pizza Pies
Traditional Slices & Pies
Add 1 Topping
Meats / Seafood
Veggies, Herbs, Fruits & Seeds
Cheeses
Sauces
Tony's Freshly Grilled Burgers
Premium Salads - Step #1
Premium Salad - Step #2
Premium Salad - Step #3
Tony's Hearty Appetizers
Tony's Hearty Calzones
Baked Entrees
Pasta Entrees
Vegetable Entrees
Chicken or Veal
Meat
Seafood
Desserts, Milkshakes & Smoothies
Coffee Bar
Beverages
Tony's Pizza Menu image 1
Tony's Pizza Menu image 2
Tony's Pizza Menu image 3
Tony's Pizza Menu image 4
Tony's Pizza Menu image 5
Tony's Pizza Menu image 6
Tony's Pizza Menu image 7
Tony's Pizza Menu image 8
Tony's Pizza Menu image 9
Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza Interior, Food, Ambiance

Stepping into Tony's Pizza, a warm and inviting atmosphere envelops you. The rustic decor, brightened by natural light, perfectly complements the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza. Whether dining in or grabbing a slice to go, the vibe remains casual yet lively, ideal for families and friends. The cheerful staff adds to the welcoming environment, ensuring a delightful experience from start to finish. You might spot a show-stopping transformable pizza pie, a fun topic of conversation to bond over with fellow diners.

Tony's Pizza

About Tony's Pizza Food and Specialties

Tony's Pizza stands out in Brooklyn for its innovative take on traditional Italian cuisine. It offers specialties that combine familiar flavors with unique twists. The stuffed Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza epitomizes this creativity and keeps customers coming back for more. The menu is extensive with 253 dishes that span pizzas, pastas, salads, and hearty appetizers. Vegan options also make an appearance, ensuring everyone can enjoy their meal without compromising on taste. Cleveland’s best-kept pizza secret, you might say.

Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza's commitment to quality stands at the core of its operations. From sourcing fresh ingredients to maintaining high service standards, every aspect drives home the restaurant's dedication to excellent dining. Ideal for the bustling Brooklyn community, it emphasizes delivering satisfying flavors with every bite.

The specialty pies showcase the restaurant's creativity, combining diverse flavors to create an unforgettable experience. Cooking up innovative dishes keeps the menu fresh and exciting, ensuring both regulars and newcomers find something to love. The vision embodies a place where anyone, from vegan diners to pizza enthusiasts, can find something they adore. It's not just a meal; it’s about forging connections over great food in a lively community atmosphere.