Tony's Pizza

Discover Tony's Pizza in Brooklyn, NY, taste the best pizza, garlic knots, zeppoles, and vegan options. Enjoy delicious slices, Sicilian pizza, cheesecake, and more at 443 Knickerbocker Ave. Call +1 718-455-9664 now!

MenuContact

Welcome to Tony's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza sits at the bustling intersection of Knickerbocker Avenue in Brooklyn, New York. This lively eatery is a haven for pizza lovers, renowned for its scrumptious slices and inviting atmosphere. The moment you step inside, the delightful aroma of baked dough and melting cheese wraps around you, promising a satisfying meal. Whether sinking your teeth into a classic pepperoni slice or indulging in the daring Bacon Double Cheeseburger Pizza, every bite delights your taste buds. Friends and families flock to this friendly local spot, creating a warm, communal vibe that feels just right. With a diverse menu and options for everyone, including vegan choices, Tony's ensures everyone leaves happy.

Location & Contact

Address

443 Knickerbocker Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, United States

Phone

+1 718-455-9664

Social Media

About

Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza
Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza has established itself as a cornerstone of the Brooklyn community, marrying traditional Italian recipes with a modern twist. Originating as a small local pizzeria, it has grown into a beloved establishment drawing diners from all corners of New York City. Tony's secret sauce ignites a flavor explosion, further elevating their pizza game, while the commitment to quality ensures only the freshest ingredients make it to the dough.

Dive deeper into Tony's offerings, and you'll discover specialty pies such as the BBQ Chicken Pizza and mouthwatering baked clams, each crafted with attention to detail.

The pizzeria prides itself on serving generous portions at reasonable prices, making it an excellent value for families and groups. The average spend of around $34.29 keeps diners satisfied without breaking the bank.

Tony's Pizza isn't just about food; it's about creating memorable dining experiences. Customers often share laughter around the large communal tables, discussing everything from sports to local events. Weekly specials, themed events, and seasonal offerings add to the allure, inviting even the most loyal patrons to try something new.

As the busiest times show, especially on Fridays, expect a lively and bustling environment that mirrors the vibrant energy of Brooklyn. You'll always find a friendly face ready to serve up a slice or two, making it feel like home away from home.

Work Hours

  • Sunday9 AM-1 AM
  • Monday9 AM-11:30 PM
  • Tuesday9 AM-11:30 PM
  • Wednesday9 AM-11:30 PM
  • Thursday9 AM-11:30 PM
  • Friday9 AM-1 AM
  • Saturday9 AM-1 AM

Tony's Pizza boasts an extensive menu featuring a remarkable 253 items, making it a go-to destination for a variety of tastes. The standout dishes include Sicilian slices, finger-licking garlic knots, and decadent zeppoles that will satisfy any sweet tooth. Each pizza starts with a perfectly crispy crust, layered with high-quality sauces and fresh toppings. The restaurant also addresses dietary preferences with a solid vegan pizza choice, ensuring inclusivity for all diners.

Comfort is a priority, so grab a plate of their creamy Alfredo pasta or a savory baked ziti to share with friends.

For those seeking lighter fare, the premium salads offer a refreshingly crisp option. The loved snack category features hearty appetizers like baked clams and artichoke flowers, which complement any pizza feast. Packed with flavors, Tony's Pizza guarantees a vibrant dining experience, perfect for any meal of the day.

Tony's Pizza

Tony's Pizza rests comfortably amidst the colorful storefronts of Knickerbocker Avenue. Its cheerful red and white signage beckons passersby, inviting them to grab a slice in a relaxed atmosphere. The interior radiates warmth and friendliness, adorned with local art and community photos that elicit a sense of belonging.

Outside, the restaurant opens onto the vibrant, bustling street life of Brooklyn, allowing diners to enjoy the local vibe.

The outdoor seating offers a laid-back space to catch the sunset while sipping on a refreshing drink. This inviting atmosphere makes it ideal for casual meet-ups and festive gatherings alike.

Customer Reviews

While recently visiting Brooklyn, my family had a serious craving for pizza, and a friend's suggestion led us straight to Tony's. Let me just say, we were not disappointed. This is genuinely great pizza that I wish I could get more often! The crust was fantastic. It managed to be thin, yet light and airy, and was cooked perfectly. The bottom was crispy, giving way to a light, chewy outer crust. The toppings were equally impressive. The sauce stands out as some of the best I've ever tasted--it was perfectly balanced, not overpowering, and applied in just the right quantity, hitting that sweet spot between not too dry or too wet. The cheese was exactly what a classic pie needs: present and flavorful without being heavy or overbearing. We enjoyed a classic cheese and pepperoni, but seeing and smelling the other options has me eager to try them on a return trip. The place was buzzing every time we passed by, and the staff was incredibly friendly. Bottom line: This isn't a paid endorsement; I just genuinely loved this place. If you're in Brooklyn and looking for an exceptional slice, run, don't walk, to Tony's.

P
Perro M.

Yo, if you want REAL ITALIAN FOOD ESPECIALLY ZEPPLOES, GO HERE! THEY HAVE DELICIOUS AND SAVORY GARLIC KNOTS AND FRESH PESTO! I WILL DEFINITELY COME BACK HERE WHEN I'M IN THE CITY!!! 100000/10

D
Dorian L.

Pizzas were delicious! Should have gotten 2 pies instead of 1. Wanted pizza for my 52nd birthday and this hit the spot. Also picked up a slice of strawberry cheesecake (so fresh & creamy) & a slice of tuxedo cake (so chocolatey). Based on my order size they tossed in a free 2 liter. Customer service was on point & the dining room was toasty warm on a bitter day. Had the newest James Bond playing while you waited.

J
Jen H.

Best pizza so far in NYC, no lie. Tony is da king who always let's me grab a slice and let's me run to get back on my grind/hustle. They treat you right here.

L
Luis C.

Was craving grandma slice and this totally hit the spot. Crunchy, and chewy! The sauce, herbs and cheese were perfect balance. I live nearby so I just did pick up. Noticed how cute the picture on the box is as I walked home and it made me smile. This is a place that cares about their food. I highly recommend it if you're craving a classic!

L
Liz P.

Excellent vegan pizza! You can create individual slices with whatever toppings they have (vegan chicken, sausage, pepperoni, cheese + regular pizza toppings). They are made to order. Crust was doughy and crunchy but not too thick. I got one veggie and one sausage. The slices are huge and around $6 each. My partner enjoyed his non-vegan pizza as well. They have vegan desserts but they didn't look great. The people working there were so helpful and nice explaining how the vegan options work. Bathroom was clean. Definitely recommend.

E
Erica M.